The situation
The owner manages by two numbers: revenue and gross margin. Both look healthy. The website is treated as the best channel because it has the highest price and a 60% gross margin, and most of the advertising budget goes there.
Gross margin stops at the cost of the product. The costs that differ most between channels come after it.
The same quarter, by channel
Take each channel down to what it contributes after shipping, platform fees, advertising and returns, and the order reverses. Wholesale has the lowest gross margin and the highest contribution. The website has the highest gross margin and keeps 9.0% of each dollar sold.
| Channel | Revenue | Gross margin | After shipping and fees | After advertising and returns | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Own website | $820K | 60% | $369K | $74K | 9.0% |
| Marketplace | $640K | 60% | $179K | $89K | 13.9% |
| Wholesale | $410K | 40% | $148K | $136K | 33.2% |
| Total | $1,870K | 56% | $696K | $299K | 16.0% |
Why the usual metric misleads
Advertising on the website returns 3.3 dollars of revenue per dollar spent, a figure most dashboards would show in green. But advertising takes 30% of website revenue, and after product, shipping and returns very little is left.
Total contribution is $299K. Fixed costs are $270K. The quarter ends only $29K above break-even, in a period that looked good on both numbers the owner watches.
What management can do with it
- Set the advertising budget by contribution per order, not by revenue per dollar of advertising.
- Test a higher free-shipping threshold on the website and measure contribution, not conversion.
- Put a number on what one more wholesale account is worth, and decide whether it deserves the time advertising gets today.
The management questionWhich channel earns money after all the costs it brings with it?
Back to Quick readsSee what a full monthly report looks like