Back to Quick reads

Analysis · Profitability

Revenue is up. Gross profit is not. Why?

A distributor beats its sales budget by 6.0% and earns almost nothing extra. The answer is not in the income statement. It is in the bridge between budget and actual.

Illustrative case, not a client.

The situation

The month closes with revenue $73K above budget. The sales team is pleased and management expects a strong result. Gross profit comes in only $2K above budget, and gross margin falls from 33.2% to 31.5%.

The income statement shows both facts. To see why the percentage moved, the margin has to be opened up into its parts.

What the bridge shows

A gross profit bridge splits the change into the drivers that management can act on. In this example, volume added $31K and list prices added $13K. Discounts took back $34K. Product mix and unit cost took a further $8K between them.

The pattern is common: the extra volume was bought with discounts. One product line, Industrial supplies (MRO), grew 13.9% against budget while its discount rate went from 4.0% to 8.6%. On $72K of additional revenue it produced $1K of additional gross profit.

Gross profit: budget to actual

March, US$ thousands. Change vs. budget by driver.

Gross profit: budget to actualAgainst a budget gross profit of $400K, volume added $31K, price $13K; discounts took away $34K, mix $4K and unit cost $4K. Net change +$2K, to $402K.Volume: +31+31VolumePrice: +13+13PriceDiscounts: −34−34DiscountsMix: −4−4MixUnit cost: −4−4Unit costNet change: +2+2Netchange
Volume and price added to gross profit. Discounts took almost all of it back.

Why it matters beyond gross profit

Commissions and freight follow volume, not margin. The low-margin sales carried full variable costs, so operating expenses rose $13K over budget and EBITDA (what the business earns from operations, before interest, taxes and depreciation) ended below plan in a month when sales beat the plan.

What management can do with it

The bridge turns a vague concern into three specific decisions:

  • Set a discount ceiling for the line where the gap is concentrated, with approval required above it. Each point of discount on that line is worth about $6K of gross profit a month.
  • Ask the sales team which customers received the discounts and what was obtained in exchange.
  • Review next month whether volume holds when discounts return to plan. If it does not, the growth was never profitable.

The management questionIs growth creating more gross profit, or simply more revenue?

Back to Quick readsSee what a full monthly report looks like

Want to apply this thinking to your business?

If the numbers are available but they are not enough to decide, we can start with the questions that matter most.

A 20-minute conversation: we understand your context, answer your questions and tell you whether the service fits. No financial information needed.

Send a message Book 20 min